AT THE FEET OF THE MOTHER
Ask Alok da

Dear Alok, There is no being in the unreal and there is no being in the real. – In this Sloka, what is meant by bhavah? I feel the meaning is this: Truth will have some representation ( sense). Where illusion (asatah) never has any representation. So anything that anyway manifested is true, untrue can never manifest. Am I right? Please clear my understanding.

This shloka from the second chapter of the Srimadbhagawatgita implies that ‘whatever is true (sat) is permanent. It will always be there (bhav). Whereas that which is not true is anyways non-existent. It cannot remain. It is in the sense of what is permanent and what is temporary, rather than illusory, unless we use the word illusory as an appearance. 

Of course, nothing can manifest out of nothing. So everything that has come into existence has come out of Truth. What seems illusory also has its origin in Truth. 

Affectionately,

Alok Da

(follow-up question:)

So there’s nothing as Illusion. Because even for a mirage to look like water, or a rope to look like a snake, there should be water and a snake in truth to make you see them as water and a snake. So, absolutely, Truth only exists, directly or obscurely.

Yes. There is Truth and its distortion. That is what illusion actually means, and not as something non-existent, for that is an impossibility. 

Affectionately,

Alok Da

Affectionately,

Alok Da

Share thisโ€ฆ

Related Posts

Pranam Sir. I am worried about my 3-year-old daughter’s safety. I am leaving her with a babysitter who is not trustworthy during my office hours. Please guide. ๐Ÿ‘ง๐Ÿป๐Ÿ›ก๏ธ๐Ÿ™๐Ÿป

I understand your concern. It is always tricky to leave the child with a maid even. Generally it is not a good idea especially because children are like sponges and absorb everything from outer habits to the states of consciousness. It is best if someone from the family, say parents, could come and stay. Creches are another solution from the safety point of view.

Read More >

Committing suicide is considered as a sin, a Ghora Karma, resulting in severe consequences. Is this result different from that of those who commit Ichha Mrutyu? How are they different? The example of Lord Rama immersing himself in the river to end his life, and that of Swami Chidananda letting his disciples to immerse him at Haridwar, is before us. Please clarify. ๐Ÿ•ฏ๏ธ๐Ÿ•Š๏ธ๐Ÿ™๐Ÿป

I suppose as with everything else, it is the intent that is important. Suicide is dark and dangerous when one does it in a state of great depression and darkness, done as an extreme step to escape from the problems and difficulties of life. But conscious withdrawal through certain means when one is conscious that the work one …

Read More >

For years, a deep and constant aspiration has lived within me to serve the nation, Sanatana Dharma, and the Divine through intellectual work. While I am dedicating myself to serious study, progress often feels slow, and much vital energy is consumed by inner conflicts and personal limitations. ๐Ÿ‡ฎ๐Ÿ‡ณ๐Ÿ“š๐Ÿ”ฅ๐Ÿ™๐Ÿป[…]

Your deeply appreciate your beautiful aspiration. I am sure The Divine Mother will fulfil it when you are ready. It is not easy to serve the Divine especially to fight for His manifestation in the world. The Yoga of the Gita shows us …

Read More >