Dear
It is a hypothetical question that looks at only one point out of many. When Sri Aurobindo was asked about speaking truth he seems to have responded that ‘Truth has to seen as a whole and not in bits and parts’. There are quite a few examples of this including, and paradoxically, the Mother’s injunction of not publishing everything in the Agenda, not publishing Sri Aurobindo’s Records of Yoga. I suppose each one decides based on the sense of truth that they intuitively feel. The motive is always most important. I had asked Jugal da about the whole incidence of the Mother and Dada. He confirmed that he himself asked this to Andre da to ask the Mother. She became quiet and then told to Andre da that She would have left the body long back if Pranab was not there! So you see we should not rush to judge the Divine Lila or anyone in haste. But if the question is simply a yes and no then surely I would do what She would ask me to do.
Affectionately
Alok Da


